I have been watching a very interesting debate on one of the adoption groups on whether waiting adoptive parents should publish the waiting child's name or picture on blogs, particularly if it is published before it was clear the writer has been given the right to adopt the child, specifically in fund raising efforts. I've been watching/reading, but I have written nothing on the subject because it is such a hot button for those involved. However, the debate has made me think.
On raising money for an adoption:
Bottom line, between the country fees, the adoption agency fees, the various medical and legal fees, and finally, but still costly, travel and "leave" from work, few adoptions transpire for less than $20,000. This year China raised the "orphanage donation" from around $2,000 to $5,000, so the cost are only going up. A fair amount of adoptive parents choose to adopt after rounds of trying infertility treatments which may have already put a $10-20,000 hit (if not more) on the savings account. So the reality for >90% of adoptive parents is that there is a significant hit to one's savings.
If savings don't exists, or don't meet the cost, fund raising occurs. I was lucky. I didn't need to fund raise. However, I don't know how we would handle the situation if I was laid off six months prior to the adoption rather than four months after. I know more than one family that stopped their search not due to a lack of desire, but due to a lack of finances. So the question arises, "if you have the heart to adopt, the funds to support daily life with one additional child on board, but not the funds for the big chuck of change that goes out the door with the legal transaction, is fund raising a valid option?" I get it. I don't view it as first choice, but I see why it happens.
On publishing a child's name;
The debate is on protecting the child. I have chosen to write in my own name. I know many bloggers that use pseudonym. I have chosen to use nicknames for the boys. I just didn't want them to Google their name someday and find things I hadn't had a chance to explain to them. But there is a debate/worry about the predator that may roam the Internet looking for kids to kidnap or identity theft. But, lastly, the real heated battle is on whether if the child gets older, and sees the old efforts, will feel like a charity case? All I can say is "Wow, I have no idea." They could feel loved, they might appreciate the efforts their parents and friends put forth, but they might be embarrassed. I don't know, but I imagine their impression of the effort might also change over time.
On Publishing a Child's Photo:
Yeah, I've put some photos out for public consumption. Is my pride overwhelming my protective instinct? I do edit my photos, nothing graphic makes it. I've thought multiple times about sharing the Little Man's massive birthmark so others would know what to expect. but each time I talk myself out of it. But did my kids say I could post their photos? Do they even understand if they do give me permission? It is an interesting topic. I'm also a little blogger to friends and family; I'm not reaching the millions of some of the impressive professional blogs. But If I was fund raising, and not yet the parent of the child, should you post photos? I understand that the photo helps the cause, makes people put a face with the effort, but maybe it is uncouth until you are the legal guardian. I think even I am guilty by about a month on my Little Man. My enthusiasm for our lives joining just blinded any critical thought on the matter. My mistake.
Bottom line-
I feel a bit bad about the debate in the adoption group. I think both sides really love and want to love their kids. Therefore these are extremely emotional topics. But I do think it is fair for the most cautious in the group to remind everyone else why we should use caution. I also think it is fair for us to debate the merits of the argument. However, in reality people are shutting down, pointing fingers and leaving the group. Hey, being a parent is a heavy responsibility. But it is generally the criticism that makes me recognize a mistake I can fix. But I love the support my friends offer as well. There is a great balance we all need.
Video with the Girls
14 years ago
.jpg)
